Since Equestria is not Earth, and possibly is in another galaxy, perhaps their sun is a LOT smaller and a LOT closer, giving Celestia (and once Twilight) the ability to move the Sun.. Also, notice in season four, in the episodes of Twilight's Kingdom, Twilight has the ability to control both the Sun and Moon after Celestia and Luna give her their powers. Another thing: also in season four, in the episodes of Princess Twilight Sparkle, when Luna and Celestia are captured, the Sun and Moon are left suspended in the middle of the sky. Just a thought (or many of them).

@Андрей Тимаков our sun is a dwarf star already.

oh and don’t forget the FIRST EVER EPISODE OF THE SHOW

That would make sense because we have seen ponies get so tried out traveling

Actually equestria's sun is the same size as the sun

@Amanda Proxima b is orbiting red dwarf. And Proxima b is the closest  exoplanet.

YAY PONIES LIVE JUST AT 4.21 LY (also joking)

Андрей Тимаков

Maybe the Sun is a dwarf star and Equestrian planet is tidally locked, but Celestia rotates the planet using her magic. And the planet's orbit is so close to star that its gravity attracts the moon, so Luna holds it on its orbit using magic.

Андрей Тимаков


Or equestria is flat
(Since equestria dosnt have time zones)
So CELESTIA litterally raises the sun.

@+[DragonessTheLatte]+ No, not really. I posted that comment a while ago and am not sure how my old comment applies to the conversation anymore lol. but Equestria is canonically round. Pinkie said so herself, unless some continuity error occurred.

@GalaxyTheDragonshifter Is mlp realistic?

Must have started what happened with flat earthers

EQUESTRIA IS FLAT SPHERES ARE A LIE DON"T TRUST THE- oh the government is literally just two ponies?

DO NOT SUB DEAD CHANNEL (SOLDIERBLUEJAY)

eh, what about gravity? it just doesn't just go away-

Or it is just like in Double Rainboom fan made episode.

@MayaMyStore Exactly. I remember that quote actually

A flat planet is not actually scientifically possible. This vid by Matpat shows the science and how flat planets aren't possible: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stBW9byJQY4

Bruh. I don’t know if this comment was being posted before the episode came out, but in the episode where the classic Hearth’s Warming Tale was told, Pinkie Pie clearly said “The Earth is round! There is no up or down!”. And even if this was posted before that episode came out, I’m sure you can find a globe in Twilight’s old library somewhere in an episode!

Or maybe  equestria is huge  ( bigger than the sun )

Actually they do because when it was night in the crystal empire it was day in Canterlot

Equestria is flat, Yep Equestria is flat

I’m pretty sure that there was a globe in  an episode.

In one of the episodes I think it was “Hearth Warming’s Eve” Pinkie states “Hate to break it to you but the earth is round there is no up or down”

equestria is literally just America in another universe its been told my mulitpule other poines in the show and maybe even the devs theres more than just equestria


Actually she does raise the sun, as shown in the episode where all the other princesses give Twilight their magic. She has to raise the sun herself.

lemon lily u might be right but i wanna watch some bangtan vids now

Not to mention, we can see that the sun doesn't rise when Twi forgets to bring it up, and she raises the sun wobbly due to her lack of control.


Celestia definitely raises the sun. And, according to Twilights Kingdom, she has the power to make it go wonky as well.


We know Celestia isn't a fraud, because Twilight stuffs up the sun/moon cycle when given her magic.

So I know this is 8 years later but I just want to say that sawtooth is wrong cuz in season 4 last two ep the sun and moon were being controlled by twilight and the sun and moon are wonkey cuz twilight doesn’t know how to control the sun and moon so celestia does control the sun. Also I just like to say that this video may be before those ep so sawtooth wouldn’t know.

@shenelle latty<br>What's that got to do with it?

@shenelle latty
What's that got to do with it?

@Bud Charles there cutie marks were gone in twilite


I recall in one of the books there was a line where they mentioned a place outside of Equestria where the  plants didnt need ponies to help them grow. the ponies thought this was unnatural. <br> so perhaps the magic is the reason for this. as in the magic use of the ponies is robbing nature of its own abilities?

I recall in one of the books there was a line where they mentioned a place outside of Equestria where the  plants didnt need ponies to help them grow. the ponies thought this was unnatural.
 so perhaps the magic is the reason for this. as in the magic use of the ponies is robbing nature of its own abilities?


Now that the Gen5 movie is out, conspiracy confirmed!
There have been no alicorns for a long time. Also no unicorn magic for a long time. [Remembering how the Hearth's Warming pageant & the play on Cellie's ones-versary said it was the unicorns who raised the sun & moon before the alicorns.]
And yet the sun's been rising apparently regularly on its own, & likely the moon too!
Heck without flight the pegasi must not have been able to control the weather nor seasons. The earth ponies apparently haven't had whatever magic which seemingly helped them work the land. And yet it looks like weather, farming, and probably seasons have been acting all on their own perfectly fine; the earth pony & pegasus cities even thrive, thanks probably to technological advances. It's as if nature forces acting like they did in the Everfree Forest w/o pony guidance has actually been a GOOD thing.

Was... was having magic actively holdiing ponykind back? Could it have been propping up a unicorn aristocracy which wasn't earning its keep on the whole, once they knew they didn't need to use their magic to keep the sun & moon going &c? Will they regain that kind of power & status now that they have horn magic again? Will pegasi become weather ponies and Wonderbolts [& Junior Speedsters & Washouts] again? Will earth ponies buck apples & make them all somehow fall into just a few baskets again in defiance of physics, and for the first time give us a decent idea what their magic actually does?


Equestria exists in our world, just somewhere in another universe, somewhere...

@Mia T. Ahem "another universe" different universe may mean different physics

Yeah totally the chances of Equestria existing is like me getting a girlfriend

@Josiah Fernandez pony Ville can be anything  so pony ville is ...... .a pony’s in a village

I herd that leged says that unicorns can be found at the end of a rainbow

Grunky The Grandpa Of Cheese yess that is true I actually saw a bunny looking like angel bunny walking down my camping street

Grunky The Grandpa Of Cheese <br>You mean an alternate universe

Grunky The Grandpa Of Cheese
You mean an alternate universe

Keith Maverick, Boy am I glad I live in america

The answer to where Equestria is is in this video: https://youtu.be/0TCcTcoRh6w

it is a alternate copy of our planet it was just never discovered by human beings

Is not a Universe or Different Planet. Equestria is located in our Planet and people says is a continent.

If you look in Equestria map. You have Vanhoover, Manehattan, Baltimare, Ponyville, Fillydelphia, etc. These city is similar in United States of America.

It means, Equestria is United States of America or USA.

Vanhoover - Vancouver
Ponyville - Louisville
Baltimare - Baltimore
Fillydelphia - Philadelphia
Manehattan - Manhattan


<b>but that’s just a theory, a game theory</b>

*but that’s just a theory, a game theory*

꧁☃𝙵𝚛𝚘𝚜𝚝𝚆𝚊𝚏𝚏𝚕𝚎☃꧂

ʍou ʇɥƃᴉɹ pᴉdnʇs ʞooʅ no⅄


It’s in the name.
My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic.
It’s all about teamwork. Celestia raises the sun and Luna raises the moon. The teamwork of the sun and moon cycle. Then we have the Pegasus Ponies delivering the seasons, they all work together to deliver summer, autumn/fall, winter, and spring (unless you’re Rainbow Dash, then you want to stop winter). Is this why it’s called friendship is magic? If so, then it creates the magic of the functions of days, nights, and the seasons.

And earth ponies are planting food. And unicorns are protectors.


when twilight had the magic she could move the sun

People from the future: “You’re wish is my command!”

Yeah, so Celestial actually raises the sun every day, but the video is also outdated so

That ep hadn't come out when he made this😑

But she did not had the magic she had a thing that raise the sun

That's true but this vid came out in 2013😂

However since Twilight is now the ruler of equestria, she has to move the sun and the moon since Celestia and Luna are retired. So the sun and moon have to be moved every .single  day.

@Josie Your Right, Season 9 Didnt Exist Back Then....

ed sweeney that's cuz she had cekestia's magic

Twilight's Kingdom = RIP Notion (of pharoah theory)

ed sweeney it's probably from a black hole that dose dis every 1000 years

but he posted the video 3 years ago so he did not know


My theory is that it IS Earth! Alright first detail, during winter wrap up they use tools, but they are using tools that we humans use, if it were their own universe they would most likely design their own tools to fit their own pony life's. Another thing you should think about is their technology, one day they are using candles as their only light source, then the next they have headphones, arcade games and weird car like speaker things, and if you look at Vinyl Scratch's headphones they are meant to fit a human head. So when twilight went to the human world she was traveling to the PAST. Then when she left the main six as humans kept using that magic and it spread throughout the human world then eventually everyone evolved, the only downside is that there is still history before the main six and memories, I have an idea though, I think that memories were just implanted. I mean this theory would explain why there are sayings like <br>" On the other hand " when there aren't hands in

My theory is that it IS Earth! Alright first detail, during winter wrap up they use tools, but they are using tools that we humans use, if it were their own universe they would most likely design their own tools to fit their own pony life's. Another thing you should think about is their technology, one day they are using candles as their only light source, then the next they have headphones, arcade games and weird car like speaker things, and if you look at Vinyl Scratch's headphones they are meant to fit a human head. So when twilight went to the human world she was traveling to the PAST. Then when she left the main six as humans kept using that magic and it spread throughout the human world then eventually everyone evolved, the only downside is that there is still history before the main six and memories, I have an idea though, I think that memories were just implanted. I mean this theory would explain why there are sayings like
" On the other hand " when there aren't hands in

Equestria. What do you think of my theory? And maybe there is a possibility that the sun shrunk, like maybe a piece broke off maybe by meteors or something. BRONY NOTION PLEASE SEE THIS!!!!


Also

I am from

THE FUTURE!!

And I’m here to tell you that your totally wrong. Equestria is on a planet.
Celestia dose raise the sun cuz twilight rates it in a later episode
And
In season 9, twilight DETHRONES celestia.

There’s my proof

Bai

I don't know if equestria exists now or not but i do have a point that in MY LITTLE PONY : FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC they have shown that dragons are also there as SPIKE is a dragon and lives in ponyville and IN PAST DRAGONS EXIST so that means WHEN DRAGON USED TO EXIST ON EARTH THE PONIES TOO EXIST AT THAT PERIOD OF TIME still yet scientists or archeologists have not found anything related to the ponies

@Divya Ahuja ohhh you will be surprised later

In india season 9 is not out yet only 6 seasons are out <br>When season 7 will come ?

In india season 9 is not out yet only 6 seasons are out
When season 7 will come ?

@Funeez meh because iam one month before you

Are you a different country then sawtooth waves because sawtooth waves seen the ending few months than other countries (im a  🇮🇩)

@Caitlin Buensuceso your no fun you know 😂

Who's really from Future<br>Do you guy have any proof

Who's really from Future
Do you guy have any proof

NOPE I AM FROM DA FUTURE!!!!

This video was posted 7 years ago, soooo yeah

I A M D A F U T U R E ! ! ! ! !


i just thought of something:

in a canterlot wedding when chrysalis reveals herself she says a line which goes like this
"Equestria has love than any OTHER PLACES i've encoutered"
she said other places
and don't go saying that talking about cantorlot in particular
remember she said EQUESTRIA
sooo, could this confirm that Equestria is just a nation?


Disproved in season 4's finale... When: SPOILER ALERT!

Twilight has to do it herself after the main boss tries to take the Alicorn magic from the OTHER three princesses... Not knowing of Twilight's ascension in the previous finale...

Now I'll is finished sorry to burst your bubble people of the past

Marion Ette that c word he use isn't a bad word?


Please revisit this topic if you have more to say given what more we know now! I've got some ideas to add:
In the MLP comic, "The Return of Queen Chrysalis," Twilight implies in at least two lines that their world is in the Horsehead Nebula.
Also, I always thought the "planet" Equestria takes place on must be flat; otherwise when the sun is high in the sky in the middle of Equestria, it must be different times of day on the rest of the planet. Also it seems like instead of revolving steadily around the planet, the moon and sun sometimes just switch quickly between day and night. Maybe the sisters have little regard for the time of day in other lands, but that doesn't seem like them.


Also, remember that Discord had the ability to change a single day to a few seconds in Return of Harmony?


Wow my crying in 2020 how flashback is this and i miss my little pony i want season 10😭😭😭

@~ Dream & Candy ~ WAIT WHAT?!?! NOOOOOOO I DIDNT EVEN KNOW IT ENDED😢

It's not Lauren's fault that there's no season 10 she know that every cartoon has an end


I actually remember that celestia said "What on EARTH ?!"

What timing what episode what season ? Please tell


Luna is actually more powerful because she needs to control all the stars as well not just the moon.

My OC is called Astra (I know very creative, the spanish version of star just like Luna= Moon and Celestia= Sun) who is the lost sister of Celestia and Luna and her job is to raise the stars and works with Luna. My other OC is called Nuba (cloud) who's job is to raise the clouds and works with Celestia

luna dosent crontrol the stars its just that you cant see them by the sun light


I believe that the magical world of Equestria do exist. I can feel it inside of me.


The geocentric theory might actually be plausible with a lot of magic as backup and if the sun was at the right distance and the right size as to not burn the planet but also not let everypony there freeze to death.


There's another thing. In the play of Hearths Warming they discovered the land of Equestria and you can't go somewhere unless you came from somewhere too.


its kinda obvious that Celestia actually raises the sun because when Twilight was controlling all of the princesses magic at once, she lowered the Moon AND raised the Sun. Plus, when she was doing so you could tell she was the one doing it by the way that they were being moved. So they didnt move themselves, it was Twilight doing it.


what about when the alicorns gave twilight all their power and she tried to lift the sun and it was going EVERYWHERE! Celestia does raise the sun


I somehow think that first theory "Celestia rotates the planet around the Sun and Luna rotates the moon around the planet" is most likely logically correct.


I'm interested in seeing the other continents of the world that Equestria is on. If MLP continues or a <br>sequel series is produced, maybe we'll see them at one point.

I'm interested in seeing the other continents of the world that Equestria is on. If MLP continues or a
sequel series is produced, maybe we'll see them at one point.

ryan macdonald My head canon gets into that. In G1, Majesty is apparently somepony who has a unique wish-granting ability, so what if she used it for evil rather than for good? Persecuted Earth ponies cross the Luna Ocean to settle in what's now Equestria.


I have one dark theory, what if a long time ago everything worked naturally but then Ponies started alter the natural cycles of their world, like day, night and weather to fit their desires and commodities but the world got damaged and could not work on its own anymore so they had to produce this cycles artificially all the time to keep their world alive, there are places like the Evefree Forest that still work naturally but Ponies are afraid of it.


Sometimes I wonder why I watch these videos, besides the fact that they are funny, because it is a show for little kids and they wouldn't go that in depth with the planet and sun and how it happens once a year and how the protagonist's hero is a fraud.


But let’s not forget that when Twilight has her magic she also raises the sun, meaning that Celestia is actually massively powerful.


The cutie mark problem that Snowfire brought up is interesting, but the princesses's  cutie marks could mean that they are fakers. I mean, even for MLP, their cutie marks are NOT at all realistic. Just compare the sun in any episode, and compare it with Celestia's cutie mark. They're soooo different! All the other cutie marks match the real item in MLP.


My theory is that Equestria is on an lonely earth like planet (without a star, booted out of its system), so Celestia uses her magic to create/controll an artificial magical sun (just big enough for the planet and much closer and smaller than our own). And Luna has her magical artificial moon that can literally block out this sun. The rest is simply explained: magic.


when Celestia gave her powers to twilight sparkle, twilight  had to rise the sun herself. That means that Celestia has to rise the sun too. She is probably way better than twilight at doing so.


Honestly, I'd say Equestria is the equalvalent to North America because of the map of Equestria is designed in one of the episodes, plus the mane 6 (especially Rarity) talk about cities just like their real life equvilants. Manehatten to Manhatten, Phillydelphia to Philidelphia, and Las Pegasus to Las Vegas. Plus, they all seem to have such easy access to these cities meaning they must be close to these cities since they seem to get there so fast.


Yes because in a "Canterlot Wedding" part 2. Queen Chrysalis said "there is more love in equestria than anywhere else"


there was that episode when twilight tried to raise the sun but it was in a pretty erratic route so Celestia DOES have the magic to move the sun


This was debunked in the S4 finale, episode 26 Twilight's Kingdom part 2.  The 3 princesses give all of their magic to Twilight, and when she wakes up, she wonders why the sun isn't up.  Since Celestia doesn't have her magic, she would not be able to raise the sun.  Twilight relises this, and she tries to raise the sun, hence it going all wonky.


Yeah there are other lands learned in other episodes like the dragon land, changaling hive, and afackastan. Forgive me for my spelling.


I always thought equstria theoretically was in the clouds like care bears just what I assumed


Yeah. If she did revolve the earth, the magical aura that appears when Unicorns and Alicorns grab something with their horns would appear on the ground, which it doesn’t.


I think that instead of the sun being a big ball of hydrogen and it being a magical form, a physical form of Celestia's destiny. Also, the moon is the physical form of Luna's destiny


Someone called RLYoshi did a thing like this. Check it out. It's a good theory, and it theorises that equestria is just earth in the far future where equestrian magic has turned everyone to ponies. It goes over some factors like how equestria is basically shapes around america, and how there are a bunch of human things CLEARLY not for ponies, like vinals headphones of the telephones, or human socks. Look it up, I can't explain.

(NOPE, NOT ADVERTISING. IT'S JUST A GOOD THEROY, AND YOU SHOULD SEE HIS AND SEE WHAT YOU THINK OF IT)


There is one problem in thinking cillestia is a fraud. In some episodes, when cillestia goes missing, the sun doesn't rise, so she is not a fraud. I do like your thinking though.


if we discoverd equestria and all the other lands (on one planet), in space, i would wonder if the people who made mlp were ponies themselves


The question I want to know is: If there are other places in the pony world, than are there other "princesses" our there? Princess Celestia doesn't seem to be 'world famouse" because in every episode she is in she is always there no questions asked, she's there.

Perhaps, if there are other contries or kingdoms there are also  other rulers, and mybe they also belive they can raise the sun and moon.


Not sure if I've already mentioned this but these ponies seem to be at a level higher to our own, hence able to move moons, planets and even something as big as the sun. Would also explain the ability to teleport themselves, levitate items and manipulate reality in some cases.
Watch Star Trek TOS Errand of Mercy.
The cartoon has just brought it down to our level for us to watch and enjoy :D

Or what about any scene from "Star Wars"?


Ever thought that Equestria might be a planet, maybe? In another solar system? (That's how Celestia's power doesn't affect our sun)


Well, Equestria looks to be shaped a lot like the United States and there are many cities and places that have names that are like cities in the US.


I wonder if maybe Celestia doesn't just grab a hold the sun with her magic and use it to pull the planet around. To any pony without the knowledge of space (we don't see any models of their solar system or globes in the show and with Twilight being such a scholar wouldn't she have one?) they would all assume she was moving the sun, but what if she's really just moving the planet?


And in pinkie apple pie when they sing "apples to the core" there is a line that says "were from equestria and <b>beyond</b>"

And in pinkie apple pie when they sing "apples to the core" there is a line that says "were from equestria and *beyond*"

It means, applejack is talking about our Countries?

Magenta so that means you have to go beyond and exactly where is beyond??!!

@Kaseyshere101 well since they say some stars are other universes,what if a star out there actually has equestria in its solar system and all of the ponies really exist?

@DJ Harpster the Animatronic i know, exactly! what, they are talking about space? equestria is definitely a continent.


Equastria has to be real I love it so much. I sometimes see night made moon in the moon. I also know there r more then 8 planets in the galaxy. So it has too


With this, You can’t never explain What happens when the storm King for hold of the magic


Celestial is a fraud? I think not! In Twilight's Kingdom, once Twilight absorbed all the alicorn magic, she had to raise the sun since Celestia couldn't. In the scene, the sun was wobbly and Twilight had a lot of trouble with this task. So I'm pretty sure Celestia and Luna are VERY real.


Actually, the theory of Celestia being a fraud doesn't work because of the season 4 finale when Celestia, Luna, and Cadence give all their alicorn magic to Twilight and she is responsible for raising the sun and lowering the moon. If this theory of Celestia being a fraud was true, Twilight wouldn't have to do anything and her magic wouldn't move the position of the sun. But, as seen in the episode, when she tries, the sun and moon go crazy and move across the sky in no specific order, which disproves this theory.

To add to that, in the episode where the everfree forest takes over and Celestia and Luna go missing, the sun and moon share the sky. This means that they are connected to the two princesses' power, which also disproves this theory.


Never question the logic of a cartoon this show is designed where sentient ponies replace humans on earth since there’s places that are named after locations in the real world such as manehatten vanhoover saddle Arabia etc. equestria i think is literally a play on the word America and the whole thing where the ponies change the seasons and make the sun and moon raise and lower is just a creative aspect on the show to help drive the plot forward


With the episode of Twilight moving the sun around during the battle with Tirek what is your new theory?


I think the people who make mlp dont really think about the science behind anything they just make it. so I guess ur channel (if the creators see it) could be helpful for further eps in mlp!! ^-^


I am shocked good sir!  How could you publicly say that Celestia is a fraud. I am ashamed...


The Brony Notion did u watch se4 finale? Twilight said: "that's weird, the sun should be up by now" and used Celestia's magic wich she consumed to raise the sun. How else would u explain that the sun was wobbling while Twilight raised the sun?


Well, Nasa did discover several planets deep within space that is very much alike to earth. One of those earth like planets could be the dragon realms to spyro's world or of course Mlp's.


well watch season 8 episode 7 and celestia raises the sun in the middle of the night to save twilights play


At 1:00
"I would subscribe to the notion..." I see what you did there!


SPOILERS AHEAD IF YOU HAVENT WATCHED SEASON 4 FINALE YET: In the season 4 finale when Twilight is given Celestia and Luna's powers, she can't handle them and she literally raises the moon in the middle of the day and puts the sun back up like 2 seconds later and then she makes the sun wobble in the sky so therefore Celestia and Luna are not frauds.


As much as I luv you I do have to say that I think celestia truly does raise the sun and luna dos raise the moon 🌚🌞 I really don't think they'd lie to the rest of equestria and all their subjects . Therefore I believe that celestia is an honest and pure leader that was born into her position along side her sister as natural Alicorn. 😊 sorry to be so blunt😅 but I still love you and the rest of your theories as I believe they definitely hold water 💯💘🦄


this is good thought considering this was made in 2013 (before season 4), but in season 4, when the princesses transfer all of there magic to twilight, she forgets to raise the sun and the sun is still not up.


So what was the sun doing before Celestia? Apparently it took five unicorns plus Star Swirl to raise the sun each day. Okay, so that's 1825 unicorns permanently losing their magic every year with the help of Star Swirl. What were they doing before Star Swirl? How was the sun being raised for the millions of years prior to the existence of ponies? Are ponies so conceited to think they're literally the centre of the solar system and the machinations of a complex ecosystem?


the only problem with this theory is well in the first two episodes. If the sun and Equestria were the same as earth then when Nightmare Moon came and took Celestia the sun would still come up, but it didn't. also there are lands outside of Equestria because in one episode the bull kind of looking guys and the Elements of Harmony have to make them feel comfortable. Celestia says the bull looking guys live FAR away from equestria.


She moves the sun. Its magic bro, it can ultimately do anything


I'm sorry saw tooth but I have to disagree. Celestia couldn't be a fraud because when tierek attacked the three princesses gave all their magic to twighlight and then it was her job to raise the sun and we saw how that played out😂


But twilight has accidentally moved the sun all over the lace on two occasions-when celestia gives twilight her magi to avoid tyrric, and when she gives twilight the sun amulet when she goes on vacation.


well,she is a magical being and alicorns are really,REALLY,strong so,maybe she does have a motherload of magic to literally raise the sun🤔,just an idea😶


Actually, in season 5 ,I believe it is in, Twilight has to raise the sun because Celestia, Luna, and Cadence were being held hostage with no powers because they gave them all to Twilight. Doing this, since it's her first time, Twilight finds it a difficult, making the sun wobble and keep changing between the sun and moon. So there's no way Celestia can be a fraud like the Pharos did if Twilight was able to move the sun like Celestia is able to. But here is also something strange that I have to get off my chest, if Equestria is one world, is there anyone else than Celestia and Luna that raise and set the sun and moon? If Celestia and Luna are from another place other than Equestria where Alicorns live, wouldn't they also raise the sun and moon? If Celestia was able to do it, wouldn't other Alicorns be able to as well like Twilight? I mean I guess you could argue and say, "Twilight was only able to raise the sun and moon because she had the princess' powers mixed with hers and Cadence's." But this leads back to another video you made. If Twilight does replace Celestia and Flurryheart Luna, then wouldn't Twilight have to learn how to also raise the Sun and moon? She would have have to have the ability to already raise the sun or else she wouldn't be able to rule Equestria if she can't even raise the sun to bring fourth the day. But also if they did leave Equestria, then they wouldn't raise the sun and moon there anymore so therefore Twilight would have to learn as well as Flurryheart. And even after the sisters left, Cadence would probably stay behind and do what she does now. Okay I've gotten WAY too off topic. My point is that's Celestia wouldn't be able to be a fraud because, still, if she would leave, I know Twilight wouldn't tell a lie that she raises the sun and moon. She would actually have the ability and I believe she would be able to have that power. So I believe it is possible to raise the sun and moon. You never know, maybe Equestria is much bigger than the sun, you have to remember that this world is nothing like Earth, I mean there's talking ponies for goodness sakes!!! XD Anyway I love your theories, and I do agree to everything else in this conspiracy and keep up the good work!!


Well, during an eternal night, the planet just stays there. Right?<br>Plus, what about eclipses and stuff? Maybe the moon DOES avolve around the planet, and when it faces the sun, then it's a moon, right?

Well, during an eternal night, the planet just stays there. Right?
Plus, what about eclipses and stuff? Maybe the moon DOES avolve around the planet, and when it faces the sun, then it's a moon, right?


Since space always makes more of itself we might find Equestria


I have an explanation to Twilight's Kingdom. What if The sun and moon happens naturally, but Celestia and Luna still have great magical power. And Twilight just screwed with the Sun and moon unnecessarily. Derp spell confirmed.


I remember in a episode the six mains did a act and in that at the end of the act they said that we will name this planet earth

Edits: I remember the episode "Hearth's Warming Eve" where the mane six were in a play and Chancellor Pudding'Head (Pinkie) said she will name this land 'earth'


What is the currency in Equestria? Please do a video about it. I want to know! Thanks in advance.


This video was probably made a long time ago because he looked different There’s a difference between the past and the future can you tell me


It has a planet. Equestria is a continent with a planet that has hippogriffs, dragons and more.

꧁𝕎𝕠𝕝𝕗𝕪 𝔸𝕟𝕟𝕒𝕝𝕚𝕤𝕒꧂


A changeling trying to convince us that Celestia is a fraud? Yeah, sounds TOTALLY LEGIT XD!

Rivermelody <del>grabs a rifle and murders him</del>

Rivermelody -grabs a rifle and murders him-

Okie doki! <b>goes up to the cashier to pay</b>

Okie doki! *goes up to the cashier to pay*

hmmmmmmm <b>picks up navy blue  glasses</b> I'll have these!

hmmmmmmm *picks up navy blue  glasses* I'll have these!

Yeah! <b>Show's you all the different glasses</b> Pick what you want and buy it.

Yeah! *Show's you all the different glasses* Pick what you want and buy it.

Ok then. Let's go to the glasses shop then!

well. technically yes. I lost them a while back.

We are in ponyvile of course! Are you sure you don't need glasses XD!

ok, guess you are right... hey, where are we?

WHAT!!! THATS IMPOSSIBLE AND INSULATING!! I was born a unicorn and have always being a unicorn! It's just when I feel like my life is in danger I can use more powerful spell's in that moment to get me to safety! I'm not able to do thing's like that naturally of course.

How about we stop this whole crazy panic about changeling's and relax?

and risk my own kind if so? If I were a changling, I would have let you keep thinking that Tia was the good guy. I would have risked the changelings not getting feed because ponies love their ruler a whole lot. Plus, how do I know that YOU aren't a changeling? Nopony else besides Twilight and the other alicorns has that much magic to go as fast as a sonic rainboom, so that's a bit suspicious if you ask me

Yeah but...If you were a changeling you would say that to get my trust!

Oh, come onnnn. I was the one who pointed out the trick in the trick, wasn't I?

true... but they need to be stopped somehow, they already took over canterlot!

I don't think we should fight them unless they fight us first. Equestria doesn't need a war!

wait wait wait... HOW THE HECK DID YOU DO THAT?! I'VE BEEN WORKING ON THAT SPELL FOR YEARS WITH NO SUCESS. arg, never mind. at least we lost'em. So, how are we gonna fight the changelings?

<b>Uses his unicorn magic to go at sonic rain-boom speed's</b>

*Uses his unicorn magic to go at sonic rain-boom speed's*

OOOOOOOOKKKKKKKKKKK!!!! <b>Run's away screaming</b>

OOOOOOOOKKKKKKKKKKK!!!! *Run's away screaming*

WELL THEN DON'T JUST STAND THERE!!!! RUNNNNNNNN FROM THE CHANGLINGS

MY MIND IS BEING NUKED!! AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!

CHANGELINGS!! HEAR OUR BATTLE CRY!!!! NEIGHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!! Wait. wouldn't the changelings WANT us to love our princess, so that they can feed on our love... the more loyalty we show to Princess Celestia, the more love we give out.... oh my gosh IT WAS A TRICK INSIDE THE TRICK

We cant let the evil changeling's try to make us loose faith in our lovely princess Celestia! It's all lie's they are saying, LIE'S I TELL YOU!

Thank you! <b>Happily eat's his cookie</b>

I... never really thought of that (I mean, I knew the theory was wrong, but I didn't connect the fact that he was a changeling.) Good for you, you get a cookie!
...
oh, right. Don't have emojis.... so how am I supposed to give you a cookie?! Let me think.... I GOT IT! your cookie will be below this sentence:
Cookie
^^^^^^^^ that is your cookie, take it and go!

I... never really thought of that (I mean, I knew the theory was wrong, but I didn't connect the fact that he was a changeling.) Good for you, you get a cookie!
...
oh, right. Don't have emojis.... so how am I supposed to give you a cookie?! Let me think.... I GOT IT! your cookie will be below this sentence:
*Cookie*
^^^^^^^^ that is your cookie, take it and go!


You do realize the Storm King and Twilight could control the sun and reverse it's rotation


If Equestira exists I want to go there and live there.


I watched mlp movie some time ago and there are other species and equestria is just a land, not a planet... Also, does that mean celestia and luna are the most important for the entire world? Because they are the ones controling day and night.

☆ | ✝ Rσуαls. ✝▕ ☆ ◥


In the episode “Hearths Warming Eve” it states that the unicorns (group of ponies) raised the sun and moon before Celestia and Luna

There's another proof that unicorns raised the sun and moon b4 Tia and Luna. In the episode "Horse Play" Spike said that "It took 5 unicorn sorcerers plus Star swirl the bearded to raise the sun"


Equestria needs to be real some where out there


Did anybody else hear "Celestia is a frog?" HAHAHAHA!!!!


Equestria is a planet? I always thought it was a region and that there were a lot of other regions in that world but that the ponies from Equestria couldn't go there


This is my thought,

There are portals in space (Milky way, Black Hole etc) So Equestria could be in the milky way or something, i think that space is Infinity Long, So Equestria could be somewhere Far far far far (4000 years later of typing far) Far far away, So nobody in rl would know about it,

I love sharing my ideas, BRO HOOF!


her magic is literally based on light/sunlight, which is why she has her cutie mark in the first place. Maybe she doesnt literally raise the sun, but is instead impowerd by it when she flies along with the sun for the summer sun celebration, same thing for luna when she flies along with the moon. Another theory is that they just use their magic that generally is strong enough to defy gravity, i mean, they are powerful alicorns after all, and some fanbase of MLP see celestia and luna and any other oc alicorn for that matter as "powerful".

Alicorns are supposed to be powerful no matter what their magic is, for example Princess Cadence's power is love , and because she is an alicorn(possibly becoming one like Twilight did), her love is powerful like celestia's and luna's magic. Same thing with twilight, her power is ummmmm...MAGIC so therefore when she becomes an alicorn, her power is also powerful especially if she puts her mind to it. And twilight had her first "god mode" when she was

A filly in "Cutie Mark Chronicals". ( I think that was the name of the episode),<br>so I wouldnt completely brush off celestia and call her a fruad. There 's a reason for everything in MLP im sure.

A filly in "Cutie Mark Chronicals". ( I think that was the name of the episode),
so I wouldnt completely brush off celestia and call her a fruad. There 's a reason for everything in MLP im sure.


You make a lot of mistakes concerning Equestria and even the size of their sun. You know there's smaller and bigger stars out there right? For all we know their star could be a small yellow neutron star that Celestia raises.


Alright, this is probably a really bad headcanon, but here goes.
A few months ago, I read a Fanfiction called Project: Sunflower. One of the many sequels and side stories contains one of the writer's OCs explanation of the sun. I can't remember it exactly, but from what I can he said it was a ball of aetheric light and heat instead of burning gases. This was his headcanon, I know, but it got me thinking.
Then I remembered his other headcanon, a way of explaining interdimensional travel; each universe has a Veil, which is essentially the fabric of reality which protects all inside. When universes scratch Veils, it is possible to move between them, but that's not important right now. I immediately thought of a sheet of thin fabric pulled across the sky, past the sun and stars visible from a flat Earth. The Earth is the center of travel, as it has the most change at any given moment (assuming the magic sun bit is accurate). It is impossible to walk of the Earth, though, as there are basically teleports at each side which will deposit you on the other exact end of the Earth. The Princesses start the sun and moon moving across the sky, and they come back after reaching the edge and passing through once each rotation.
So yeah. That was a thing.


This theory is proven wrong in season 4 when twilight herself must raise the sun.


space is sooooo big that equestria could be real

space is sooooo big that equestria could be real

Wait up hold a freaking second ( and sorry for my language ) it's a TV show it doesn't exist HOW CAN WE SEE IT EVEN hasbro made so it's verified that equestria is not real ( no comments or likes or replies the notifications annoy me )

Sadly our universe expands so fast that we can’t reach those parts

Sadly our universe expands so fast that we can’t reach those parts

Year 2030 we have spaceships from star wars that can travel throughout the universe

Year 2030 we have spaceships from star wars that can travel throughout the universe

If you really want to meet these cute little ponies in the future then let's start world war 3 or a nuclear war

Hey, I feel sry for Luna And NIGHTMARE MOON.

Hey, I feel sry for Luna And NIGHTMARE MOON.

+cabbitt is awesome<br>Technically there's a fraction of infinite universes containing the qualifications for what we would describe as, "Equestria."

+cabbitt is awesome
Technically there's a fraction of infinite universes containing the qualifications for what we would describe as, "Equestria."

ok 1 prove it and 2 the universe is infinite

ok 1 prove it and 2 the universe is infinite

The Brony Notion what do you mean?(゜-゜) omg this emoticon (T_T) looks like the cry child spirit from FNaF also can you recomend a screen recorder for me to try please and thanks.

Rob Driscoll beautiful just beautiful also I read everything and it's kind of weird but beautiful just beautiful

The Brony Notion soooooo unicorns ARE real?

The Brony Notion soooooo unicorns ARE real?

wait a sec...I NEED TO SEE ALL THE PONIES,AND THEY'RE ALL MINE,MIIIIIINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

wait a sec...I NEED TO SEE ALL THE PONIES,AND THEY'RE ALL MINE,MIIIIIINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

cabbitt is awesome   Ehhh I don’t think it’s real

cabbitt is awesome   Ehhh I don’t think it’s real

The Brony Notion  I WILL DESTROY YOU YOU EVIL THORAX

Lol

The Brony Notion  I WILL DESTROY YOU YOU EVIL THORAX

Lol

Not only is there enough space For equestria to exist in space but equestria could also and probably does exist in another dimension.

According tot the web equestria is real :P

According tot the web equestria is real :P

cabbitt is awesome totally......... (sarcasim) WAIT, DID HE JUST SAY CELESTIA IS A FROD?! (not sarcasim....)

Aperently Equestria is not so far as we could expect because in episode 2 in season 2 (It's About Time) Twilight mentioned "Horsehead Nebula" that exist in our universe (in Orion's constellation) and if she could see it with her primitive (no offense) telescope it gives us some concept about how close to  "Horsehead Nebula"  Equestria is.
Just my opinion :3
What do you guys think about it ?

cabbitt is awesome how would Lauren fuast know that tho?

cabbitt is awesome how would Lauren fuast know that tho?

cabbitt is awesome it is real. Don't know exactly where it is, but it exists.

cabbitt is awesome it *is* real. Don't know *exactly* where it is, but it exists.

cabbitt is awesome IT IS REAL . I CAN FEEL IT !!!

cabbitt is awesome IT IS REAL . I CAN FEEL IT !!!

no maybe its another dimension just like in EqG :D

no maybe its another dimension just like in EqG :D

actually space is not that big because of the multiverse theorys yes it is big but not that big but it is big anuff for other solar systems so mlp could exist I mean nasa found plenty of planets out side are solar system that could sustane life so yeah but also that means dc and marvel could be real or Thomas and friends and spongebob could be real I mean nasa has got very faint singnals of communication from other solar systems but cant stay in  contact cause there like detress singnals

+The Brony Notion are you sure cause I am GETTING EXCITED TO HEAR ABOUT That!!

+The Brony Notion are you sure cause I am GETTING EXCITED TO HEAR ABOUT That!!

Hey when technology evolves enough to when we can speak to animals maybe we could ask the oldest horse in the world because he has the most wisdom! ITS BULL PROOF!!!!

no talking pony's pony's with wings and horns nee

no talking pony's pony's with wings and horns nee

+Berry Fizz I agree. I mean if she was a fraud then would Luna be a fraud? Luna was trapped in the moon by Celestia. Does Luna actually controll the Moon AND the Sun according to TheBronyNotion's conspiracy? I'm not sure. I hope he makes a video about it soon to clear up some confusion.

+Berry Fizz well she's fat from all the cake she eats

+Berry Fizz well she's fat from all the cake she eats

@deathxanamon I think she eats ice cream

@deathxanamon I think she eats ice cream

I think that TheBronyNotion's conspiracy about Celestia is correct she is a big fat fraud

I think that TheBronyNotion's conspiracy about Celestia is correct she is a big fat fraud

I'm going to take a dump and watch a Netflix show

I'm going to take a dump and watch a Netflix show

@Isaac Beverly I think you might find Ben Affleck in the wormhole

@Isaac Beverly I think you might find Ben Affleck in the wormhole

@Isaac Beverly may i tag along?<br>I <3 Luna!

@Isaac Beverly may i tag along?
I <3 Luna!

+Kittie53 I'm coming with,I want to see the princesses.

+Kittie53 I'm coming with,I want to see the princesses.

+Zoes StopmotionStudios I can help,I'm building one to a near by dimension,I guess I can make a stop at Hogwarts.

+Katherine 85 well now you can if your willing to do it?
comment

yes

or

no
you decide.

+Katherine 85 well now you can if your willing to do it?
comment

yes

or

no
you decide.

+James Barler finally someone that gets me and you're correct we can't possibly go there we will need the power of wormholes to that or something I've been trying to get to work. comment to figure it out.

+Emmanuel Arce what he said that and thank you for reading my comment.

+Emmanuel Arce what he said that and thank you for reading my comment.

+cabbitt is awesome If Equestria does exist I want to go there and live there.

+cabbitt is awesome If Equestria does exist I want to go there and live there.

+stargazer3593 what is it with peapol and worlds of derpys?

+stargazer3593 what is it with peapol and worlds of derpys?

Drop Pop Candy - Undertale Fan Animation IS AWSOME SO WATCH IT

Drop Pop Candy - Undertale Fan Animation IS AWSOME SO WATCH IT

+James Barler you should, they're very cold animals

+James Barler you should, they're very cold animals

@James Barler have you ever rode a tauntaun they're from the planet Hoth, they actually exist, I've seen one on screen before

yeah being able to study new sciences that completely defy our own. it would be cool

yeah being able to study new sciences that completely defy our own. it would be cool

a believer of what? that there are infinite universes? yes. that Equestria is real. not nessicerily I'm not saying that it's not possible, just that I don't think we can ever find out

@Wyatt Gibson It's called riding my pony

@Wyatt Gibson It's called riding my pony

+cabbitt is awesome  Thats actually true!

+cabbitt is awesome  Thats actually true!

+cabbitt is awesome it could as well even in another universe. reason why is that there are infinite probabilities so infinite universes.

@Wyatt Gibson because Genuwine had a song that'll make you a believer

@Wyatt Gibson because Genuwine had a song that'll make you a believer

@Emmanuel Arce just let him dream, man. god why are you not fun?

@Emmanuel Arce just let him dream, man. god why are you not fun?

@Libby Plays oh yes because turning into ponys is the answer why there's superman that had wonder woman ride his pony

My little pony my little pony my little pony my little pony my little funny funny funny my little funny my little bunny I am having a smile my little bunny my little funny my little bunny bunny chubby chubby chubby I'm jumping Nappanee that is so chubby in a restaurant going to the fancies open funny funny funny funny my little bunny bunny bunny bunny I have a smile to my lip song yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah I'm speaking wait what am I even saying what in the world my little pony pony pony my little my little funny funny my little bunny bunny bunny bunny bunny bunny I have a smile my my bunny bunny bunny bunny bunny bunny bunny go to restaurant in the banana bunnies go to the food store dad I love that I'm singing a song but it is a staple go to a restaurant to another mom and then he does and you are in the disrespect in 1000 years later yeah I am of you hello hello today today I am I am stupid yay ￼

I agree and if u enter  that world you would turn into a pony right?

I agree and if u enter  that world you would turn into a pony right?

@Isaac Beverly I'm sure the Avengers know about this, Captain America once told a pony to ride his bronie

+The Brony Notion so basically your saying beyond or visible universe there could be a plant with it visible universe coming in to ours,you are correct but the universe is not infinite,you are thinking of the 6th dimension or other wise known as the omnivorous were everything that ever happened or will happen or that could happen,exist beyond this universe are end less possibilities so there is a dimension were ponies take the place of humans,so can I even call this science?

Then how would Lauren Faust now of this place

Then how would Lauren Faust now of this place

@Ultraviolet Pikachu you should because master yoda is chillin there also

@Ultraviolet Pikachu you should because master yoda is chillin there also

@Supersmoothie04 fuck the ponys, ride the megazord

@Supersmoothie04 fuck the ponys, ride the megazord

+Supersmoothie04  Yes Ponies into the sunset!!!!!!!

+Supersmoothie04  Yes Ponies into the sunset!!!!!!!

+cabbitt is awesome I HOPE SO I WANT TO RIDE A PONY INTO THE SUNSET

+cabbitt is awesome I HOPE SO I WANT TO RIDE A PONY INTO THE SUNSET

+Jade Cipher It would take Ωπbillion years

+Jade Cipher It would take Ωπbillion years

+cabbitt is awesome If so I'm packing my bags and of I go! :)

+cabbitt is awesome If so I'm packing my bags and of I go! :)

maybe we can visit the power rangers if they are not in Japanese form

maybe we can visit the power rangers if they are not in Japanese form

@***** What Bible are you reading? Cuz I'm pretty sure it doesn't say anything about Zeus.

@***** What Bible are you reading? Cuz I'm pretty sure it doesn't say anything about Zeus.

+The Brony Notion Ok... Who wants to build a portal to hogwarts with me?

+The Brony Notion Ok... Who wants to build a portal to hogwarts with me?

Doesn't mean it can't exist in another galaxy :)<br>Anything is possible until proven otherwise.

Doesn't mean it can't exist in another galaxy :)
Anything is possible until proven otherwise.

@KronixWolf Yeah I know, but it's hard to imagine it.

@KronixWolf Yeah I know, but it's hard to imagine it.

@Painting.Strides But remember, the vastness of space is so large that one day, maybe one day, we will kind Equestria. The universe goes on forever. If we haven't found it yet, it's possible. IMO anything can be possible.

It is possible, but you have to remember that Equestria is made up of cartoon horses....erm..as far as we know, horses come from earth.

+Jade Cipher I don't think it would take THAT long to reach the end of our solar system. Seeing how not too long ago a satellite reached Pluto.

+cabbitt is awesome if Equestria does exist I wanna go there this instant.

+cabbitt is awesome if Equestria does exist I wanna go there this instant.

+rapheal tmnt girl       I'm from 2015 and I'm telling you about super mario maker

+rapheal tmnt girl       I'm from 2015 and I'm telling you about super mario maker

+cabbitt is awesome lol yeah yeah yeah sooooooooooo cool <3

+cabbitt is awesome lol yeah yeah yeah sooooooooooo cool <3

@Sugar Kookie101 She already has enough nightmares!

@Sugar Kookie101 She already has enough nightmares!

@Princess Luna look the equestrian planet thing we believe to be true has already developed technology to reach us! Send us scoots

@Jade Cipher I future you might meet vinyl though. if your wondering how this will work I have came up with a good idea for nasa to use,. Basically they make a space ship with everything needed for life then send out on that space ship a couple married couples that are planning to have children in the future. Then some day the children of the children and so on and so fourth they will meet an alien race! I would really like to be one of them to have children so in one of my future lifes , possibly one of my childrens children life, I chould meet an alien race.

@CMBob DankMemicorn Wtf I'm being philisophical on a video about multicoloured ponies on a website that was originally a dating website.

@cabbitt is awesome Everything is real. There is no way to disprove anything because we can't know if we are experiencing the same world as everyone else. Our reality could be just a dream of sorts. There is no real way to separate reality from fabrication.

@Lauren Savannah a black hole is not a hole. It's just a huge amount of matter in little to no volume. They aren't magical holes. Wormholes actually are something like a portal.

I WOULD BE TELLIE NELLIE AND MY SIS WOULD BE SINGING SHINER!! 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮WE WOULD LOOK SOOO EPIC

+The Brony Notion HEY!! DONT BE HATIN ON CELESTIA!!    😜

+The Brony Notion HEY!! DONT BE HATIN ON CELESTIA!!    😜

@Jennifer Maher Okay I won't question you!

@Jennifer Maher Okay I won't question you!

@cabbitt is awesome I believe its real. Unicorns are real, dude. I've been there.

@cabbitt is awesome I believe its real. Unicorns are real, dude. I've been there.

I wanna see Queen Cristalys and become part of the Changeling Swarm XD

I wanna see Queen Cristalys and become part of the Changeling Swarm XD

@The Brony Notion ok so if it can exist it will,so does that mean equestria is real?!?!?!? cuz if it is i wanna go see rainbow dash!

<b>Gasp</b> Does that mean my world of Derpy's are real!?

*Gasp* Does that mean my world of Derpy's are real!?

Beyond the black hole is an event horizon.

Beyond the black hole is an event horizon.

@cabbitt is awesome it should GO OUT THEIR PEOPLE AND FIND IT. Even though it would take over 10,000 years to get out of our known galaxy. O3O NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO ILL NEVER MEEN VINYL

Ya because who knows what Is bewound the back hole and sorry not that good of a speller

Ya because who knows what Is bewound the back hole and sorry not that good of a speller

@cabbitt is awesome  Or if you believe in multiple dimensions.

@cabbitt is awesome  Or if you believe in multiple dimensions.

In an infinite universe, anything that can exist, does exist!

In an infinite universe, anything that can exist, does exist!


if the planet does travel in a oval, then how does celestial raise the sun for the play


wow he’s videos have changed so much. i’m a good way tho. btw i love your videos


Okay, so I get the sun would be next to IMPOSSIBLE to move, but what if Celestia wasn't the only one rotating the sun? I mean, she only raises and sets the sun over Equestria right?  So, this means there ARE other alicorns like you suggested in another video, but they are in different parts of the world, and multiple of them, to help move the sun around the world. Still, one alicorn wouldn't be enough to move the sun even a quarter of the way around the earth, so maybe there are more than one, like, for example, maybe four alicorns in each quarter of the way around the earth, this would make moving the sun a lot easier. As for moving the moon, they wouldn't need HALF the alicorns as raising the sun so there may be less of the moon raising ones. If this is wrong, then I have a backup theory. So Maybe there aren't as many alicorns as I mentioned earlier, or maybe there is an alicorn civilization like you suggested in your other video, however many alicorns there are, they could be moving the earth with the magic, instead of the sun and moon. The second one is less believable because it would mean they'd have to be using their magic all day, every day, but this is just a theory. Also, the conspiracy theory was really logical and made a lot of sense. I hope you read this if you do thanks and you should think about it because your a lot better at analyzing than me, if not, oh well. ;~;


Maybe the world of Equestria is flat? I know it doesn't make any sense in our universe... but I doubt the My Little Pony world is supposed to be in our universe anyway. Anything could be possible...

Snowy, Maybe the andromeda universe has equestria???

FLUFFY UNICORNS AND RAINBOOWS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


He knows how to train your dragon?!! AMAZING LOVE THAT CHANNEL!!!!!


I like to think Equestria is in the same universe as Narnia, think about it, Pegasi, unicorns and “earth ponies” exist in Narnia and can talk, also although the world in Narnia is flat, the world in mlp is never said to be round


in "A Bird In The Hoof", Celestia says "Where on EARTH would you get such an idea?" If you listen close, Celestia says Earth.


Dude, just, I mean, c'mon. Equestria is MAGICAL!!! Don't try to apply it to science!? WHAT WERE YOU THINKING!!!!??


My theory is that Equestria is really underground, maybe in a massive cavern or something.


Being her special talent, I would SUBSCRIBE TO THE NOTION of Celestia literally revolving the sun...


Ok wait. I'm having a conspiracy theory. If Princess Celestia is princess then that should mean she is the daughter of a queen or at least having a mom because we all know that no matter how special a pony is they were born like everyone else. So if Celestia and Luna do have a mother, where is she? Maybe she rules another place that is not equestria because there is most likely other place then equestria. Does she have even more power than Celestia and Luna? Or maybe she died a long time ago and the princesses are too sad (or too busy) to mention her. Well maybe maybe not. It's just a theory.


i dont care if this happens later but when twilight takes on luna, celestia, and cadences powers she freaks out about the sun not being up remembering its her responsibility now and she raises the sun and lowers the moon making them go in crazy directions so this debunks your celestia and luna being frauds theory


Maybe the planet on which Equestria's on is much much bigger than the sun. And the universe is way bigger than we think


My question is "Is the world flat in my little pony" I lost my thought process while writing the comment but I did have a point


In the MLP movie, the storm king could move the sun by the wand that contained Celestia's magic too


when he said "you think this is bullcrap,thats what she wants you to think" is said "THATS WHAT A CHANGLING,natural enemy,would say"


Ya I know space is endless! I believe Equestria is real!


One day they will learn how to travel at the speed of light, then they will find the equestrian planet.<br>But I bet either they will kill them all, have a war, or capture one to test on it.

One day they will learn how to travel at the speed of light, then they will find the equestrian planet.
But I bet either they will kill them all, have a war, or capture one to test on it.


Equestria COULD be on another planet. So the planet might be bigger that the sun, making it so Celestia COULD actuly make the sun move... so yeah.

ALSO I think the people who made MLP PROBABLY just made there show without thinking about the "location" or the "science".


What if equestria's sun is the same size and distance away as the moon?


My friend and i have a theory and the theory is....it just a cartoon so the producer just want to make the cartoon interesting. All that happened in the show we can't really understand  even if we have a sycologic theory that just not gotta solve what happening in equestria<br>Well that is just me and my theory.

My friend and i have a theory and the theory is....it just a cartoon so the producer just want to make the cartoon interesting. All that happened in the show we can't really understand  even if we have a sycologic theory that just not gotta solve what happening in equestria
Well that is just me and my theory.


Now thanks to the movie we know there are so much more


I hope equestria is real, and we are just on another planet.


I know that this is an outdated video, but Twilight's Kingdom Parts 1 & 2 proved this theory wrong.


But in that episode where they tell the story of how Aquestria was made, Pinkie says "the EARTH is round. There is no up or down." That must mean Aquestria is on Earth.


When shining armour and cadence banished the changlings they make them go out if canterlot and that place is very dull and in the equestrian map it is not there so i say that there is more lands then just equestria


If you look at the episode where the princesses give twilight their powers the sun doesn't rise until twilight makes it even then it rises awkwardly. Also what if their planet is actually different in realitive shape then earth say maybe oval or egg like and it is the center of their solar system now imagine this before the sisters and discord the sun and moon were stationary and wouldn't move now remember how strong alicorn Magic is what if instead of the sun being huge it was maybe either half our Suns size and was closer to the planet that would require less effort or if their planet wasn't the center that celestia is moving instead the planet around the sun starting a revolution manually and Luna the starts the slingshot effect at night giving enough force to get around sun and moon. Sorry if it's all out of order and crazy I was having trouble formulating it sensibly.

Actually I thought of something extremely crazy what if the reason celestia can't do anything is that through out the day she is controlling the sun so it stays in order  and maybe Luna to enter others dreams is brodcasting to the moon for it to reflect and be like a satellite dish!


Let's see, Celestia isn't a fraud. She just makes it so that the Sun does it job. And besides, I think that the writers have some work with this.


0:49 to be honest its a completely different universe so maybe we should stop using "OUR" laws of psychics into theirs cause they have different laws of psychics


Well now we know the magic really raises the sun because the sun didn't rise until Twilight did it in the season 4 2 final episodes


its either a computer simulation or its on a massive space station of some kind.


this always confuses me because it celesta and luna rise the sun and the moon now that how did they rise before they came into power because when we see the history of Equstra before they where there they have day and night, also if we are assuming the planet is round then doesn't that mean they would have to be always up to make the sun and the moon move around the planet because its always day/night somewhere or do other pony have the same task on the other side of the planet? and while I'm on about the history why is the flag of Equstra of luna and celesta well before they even showed up there?


Um, Did'nt Twilight Raise the Sun in one of the episode's?

@Mila Season 4 episode 24 and 25 I think somewhere in the 24-26 category def.

@Mila the episode "Twilight's Kingdom" where Tirek tries to steal the princesses' magic and the princesses give their magic so Twilight would defeat Tirek with the 3 princesses' combined magic

@Halie Emch last episode of season 4 I'm pretty sure

Starlynn yes but she put it all around the sky,not able to control it like the princess

Curly Bug no she didn't! Celestia did! Not Twilight! Go watch MLP. Edit: That horseman guy is Tirek.

Starlynn becuse the princesses gave their magic to twilight to portect from this horseman guy? And also he can get their magic away then he can have all the magic in the world but at the end thats how twilight got her castle so ya woah ive been on the chat box a lot!🤔😁

yes she did. when princess celestia's powers were taken by twilight(by princess celestia's orders) before tirec could twilight ended up having to raise the sun... not very well but she did it... so yes she did raise the sun in one of the episodes
spelling corrections are the following:
episodes
didn't

Uhhhh......no, idiot. Celestia did. Twilight.....what did I do......oh! Twilight did a firework shaped as her cutie mark star. You know NOTHING about MLP. Go watch it.

Cuz the princesses "cadence luna and celestia " giv her all of there power and twi twi got her wavy this at her hair

Starlynn yes she did but that episode is when twilight had all the prinnvess powers soo.... ya

Actually Equestria is a country not a planet

Actually Equestria is a country not a planet

Starlynn because the other 3  doesn't Beleive that Tirek Knows there is a fourth Princess  So they gave there magic to Twilight sparkle that's why she raised up the sun and Moon once. DID U REALLY SEE THE FULL EPISODE OF TWILIGHTS KINGDOM PART 1 AND 2 SHOULDN'T U KNOW DIS

Starlynn She did raise the sun, but had lots of trouble, It was umm Twilight’s kingdom!

Yeah but for that special occasion.
It was interesting to see, though, that her mane began waving and the Princess' didn't anymore so my theory is that a Princess has to do something really and I mean REALLY helpful or have  REALLYYYYYYY important element to do for their part.

Let's look at Tia and Luna for example:
Tia makes the sun rise every morning which is very important to the Balance System, same with Luna's moon and that is why they have a wavy mane!
Twilight and Cadence, on the other hand, only give friendship or love to others like we saw Twilight do numerous times and Cadence do as a child with the two arguing ponies in Canterlot in the first part of A Canterlot Wedding.
PHEW

Yeah but for that special occasion.
It was interesting to see, though, that her mane began waving and the Princess' didn't anymore so my theory is that a Princess has to do something *really and I mean REALLY* helpful or have  *REALLYYYYYYY* important element to do for their part.

Let's look at Tia and Luna for example:
Tia makes the sun rise every morning which is *very* important to the Balance System, same with Luna's moon and that is why they have a wavy mane!
Twilight and Cadence, on the other hand, only give friendship or love to others like we saw Twilight do numerous times and Cadence do as a child with the two arguing ponies in Canterlot in the first part of A Canterlot Wedding.
*PHEW*

Starlynn Yes see!I did with celestia magic!

Starlynn Yes see!I did with celestia magic!

Starlynn Yes three times in one episode TWilights KIngdom I believe

oh for god sake read up or even bother to WATCH THE EPISODES. She has Celestia, Luna and Cadence's magic to protect em.

@RyuuAMcCF that's what I said!! IKR tho<br>

+Starlynn I think she tried,but she didn't do it very well. And it was only with Celestia's granted magic to her.And it was pretty much just her failing to be able to do everything all the other alicorn's do because the gave her their magic to keep it safe.

First episode, Season one! Luna prevented the sun from rising on time....proof right there the alicorns have the power to move the sun and moon--or at the very least control the rotation of the planet as well as the moon.

Ya because she had the princesses magic including celestia so Ya.., this is wrong 😂

Agreed, the sun also made weird wiggling movements, not an axis rotation, it was being controlled.

+kendra wang ya, but that happened after this video was made.

@Starlynn yeah the episode where the alicorns tansfer their magic to her

+Starlynn Actually, you don't have to wait for Season 4, which was after this video was made.

Just look at Episodes 1 & 2 of Season 1--Luna prevented the sun from rising for hours, if not a full day (the time it took to walk to the destroyed castle).

One way that the sun could be easily moved is if it started out as a moon of the planet & somehow became the glowing life-giving orb in the sky. Plants only need a source of light to generate oxygen. If magic could make one of the moons white hot, its blackbody radiation would give the world the same light we get from our sun. Read the DisQord Continuum series at FimFiction to see how easily that could be done ;)

She had Celestia's, Luna's, and Cadence's magic to do so.

Actually this video was made in 2013 so no season 4 yet...

Yes but in this year season 4 was still going to be made and it was in season 4 but yes is good point

@Çαℓℓ ℳε cяαzү ℒℴѵℯ pretty sure its the season 4 finale...

Yes and she. Only did it cuz she got the power from Tia so the princess powers will be safe from tierk soo Tia is not a fruad

@Çαℓℓ ℳε cяαzү ℒℴѵℯ ,I remember

@Çαℓℓ ℳε cяαzү ℒℴѵℯ ,I remember

I think the video was made be4 that episode.

I think the video was made be4 that episode.

@DerpyDerp Productions11 I think its called twilights kingdom.

Lol I know I check dates and stuff but I was just answering her question :P

Dude, he did this review BEFORE that episode... IK IK UR A GIRL so dont get mad w/ me 😅

@Mila Vavan its the episode where she gets all the princesses alicorn magic. My mind is going completely blank at the moment but its either the second to last or last episode of season four.


this theory is what celestia wants you to think: twilight can raise the sun with celestia's magic but it's really hard


equestria is a kingdom, like a country, since yakyakistan is like a neighbouring country.its is also said that equestria has borders


Actually...I actually kinda agree with u on the "celelstia is a FROD" thought. If you think about it, Celestia has shown her playful side a few little times in the show, shes also known as trollestia, and she does kind of look like shes faking in the summer sun celebration... If the frod thingy is true, I think in the summer sun celebration she just uses her magic to levitate a nearby book or something as the sun rises. anybody with me??


this theory is literally does celestia actually raise the sun instead of where is equestria

my questions remain unanswered


what if the sun is actually smaller in the earth and there in a different universe/dimension? she could be staging it but it couild be possible


If you watch The Season 4 finale the you will know Twilight had to raise the sun, and it was going all over the place before it was place correctly.


Who else is watching older videos here in 2020?😅


I totally believe you are right <br>P.s. Big fan of yours 😍😍

I totally believe you are right
P.s. Big fan of yours 😍😍


You know that Equestria should be HUGE because if it can fit a ursaminior than it should be WAY bigger than earth.


Remember in Princess Problem,  Celestia said that raising the moon was easier than raising the sun. know I am no theorist but could it be that the moon was easier because it was smaller in equestria?

Avry Johnson The moon is closer, smaller, and lighter. The reason why we can experience total eclipses is that the moon is 400 times smaller than the sun, while also being 400 times closer.


if you really want to know the realest answer Equestria is a place in england (or a horse farm) with a few houses near the farm it is known for


what if that the sun, was only about 3000 miles from the land, and the sun was about the same size of the moon. then the planet if in fact flat. (check out the flat earth theory's, bit absurd but for equestria it feels more plausible)