Hey Brony Notion, I just had a theory...why exactly did Princess Celestia choose Twilight<br>to ge a princess? Yes, she had a lot of accomplishments, but she also had a lot of flaws. This is the same for all of the other characters in the Mane Six. I think it may be because Twilight is Celestia's most faithful student, and that's where my theory comes into play. I think Celestia was afraid of losing Twilight. And what I mean is normal ponies and other animals aren't immortal, so they can't live forever even if they wanted to. However, princesses are immortal, and giving Twilight the role as a princess not only showed Celestia's adoration for her, but also that she wants to be with her forever. Let me know what you think.

Hey Brony Notion, I just had a theory...why exactly did Princess Celestia choose Twilight
to ge a princess? Yes, she had a lot of accomplishments, but she also had a lot of flaws. This is the same for all of the other characters in the Mane Six. I think it may be because Twilight is Celestia's most faithful student, and that's where my theory comes into play. I think Celestia was afraid of losing Twilight. And what I mean is normal ponies and other animals aren't immortal, so they can't live forever even if they wanted to. However, princesses are immortal, and giving Twilight the role as a princess not only showed Celestia's adoration for her, but also that she wants to be with her forever. Let me know what you think.

Celestia didn’t choose Twilight to become an Alicorn, Twilight earned the power after completing Star Swirl’s spell. If Twilight failed, then she wouldn’t have turned into an Alicorn and Celestia would have waited for another opportunity for Twilight to earn her wings.<br>The only thing Celestia “chose” was HOW Twilight would be tested.

Celestia didn’t choose Twilight to become an Alicorn, Twilight earned the power after completing Star Swirl’s spell. If Twilight failed, then she wouldn’t have turned into an Alicorn and Celestia would have waited for another opportunity for Twilight to earn her wings.
The only thing Celestia “chose” was HOW Twilight would be tested.


Please do flight to the finish. I feel as though the moral was never clearly stated; whenever you get a chance, I think it would be a good episode to analyze!

Yes!! This one was never really, confirmed I guess?


2 words: Jurassic Park. Why? it fits in with this episode. Don't try and contral nature it will back fire and something tragic happens, It happened in this. They tried to contral nature it back fired and flutter bat was born. so yeah.


It's been confirmed that Flutterbat may be returning in Season 5.

confirmed that maybe she will be... so really not confirmed for sure XD


I've always believed that nature has laws for a reason if we keep pushing forward we're mostly to get pushed back


I'm not sure the backfiring spell was meant to warn against GMOs; after all, the bats themselves were ignoring the plants as expected.<br>No, the spell was meant to force AJ to consider the bats' point of view. Now that the culprit is one of her friends, who can't help herself... well, the bats couldn't help themselves either, could they?

I'm not sure the backfiring spell was meant to warn against GMOs; after all, the bats themselves were ignoring the plants as expected.
No, the spell was meant to force AJ to consider the bats' point of view. Now that the culprit is one of her friends, who can't help herself... well, the bats couldn't help themselves either, could they?


Can you do pinkie pride? That would be SO awesome! Thanks :-)

mia ross I think it would be awesome too totally agree


The moral of this story is Fluttershy is right. Even though Applejack has evidence of the bat's destruction. Even though they DID destroy massive amounts of crops. Even though Fluttershy had ZERO evidence of the supposed good the bats would provide nor provided any. Even though any possible benefits would take far too long to happen. Even though she says the bats are all warm and fuzzy, but the only time they are is during her portions of the song. Every other time they're non-sapient animals. And Twilight is a friggin' IDIOT who can't seem to figure out her mind-alteration spells are massively stupid and don't work.

And Applejack was wrong. Despite the famine that happened. Despite Granny Smith telling her about the bats. Despite her being an apple farmer and knowing about these pests. Despite Fluttershy again being completely wrong about them.

Fluttershy was right because she's cute. All AJ has on her side is facts, logic and evidence.


Great video, and I would recommend either Keep Calm and Flutter On (one of my favorite episodes because of Fluttercord ship fodder) or maybe Magic Duel, since that episode had a message about the importance of teamwork to pull off what appears to be impossible.


Please Brony Notion, do a Dear Princess Celestia episode on Gilda the Brush Off. It's one of the only episodes that acknowledges the importance of recognizing a true friend from a fake one, and would be really unique to analyze. It sort of bugs me that MLP seems to stress keeping every friend you make, but some friends can be really toxic.


This is my 4th comment on this video but when I see your theists and background knowledge it gets me thinking so I've just got to say your doing a good job on these videos


You should have made you background trees look as if the bats had gotten to them, that’s would have been cool.


I find it funny that Granny never 'finished' the story of the VFB, given that one more line would have been VERY helpful. The last scene, Granny comes back and looks surprised at the VFB's appearance. AJ explains what happened and Granny tells AJ off for trying to be a mass murderer (you know fans would think it regardless!!). She would then tell AJ that the very next season, more trees grew and produced MORE fruit, better quality fruit, and larger fruit at that. (The one HUMONGOUS apple doesn't count because that's 'Apple Family' magic... thing...)


Who was that guy at the end?

I always loved Bats! Mostly the song I guess, but we do need more episodes about Applejack and Fluttershy, your favorite and mine favorite.(Though Fluttershy is my second favorite.)

I'd like you to do "Just for Sidekicks", I know I keep asking, sorry, but I wonder what is there to that episode? I have a lot of respect for the writers of MLP so even though I'm not fond of that episode, I still want to know what it did right.


Wait, you didn't make one of the morals "Friendship is magic"? That's new XD


Bats is my least liked episode of mlp because the moral unfairly falls on Apple Jack when she really didn't do anything wrong, in fact she was just as much a victim of peer pressure as Fluttershy. It was Twilight who owed the apology at the end, not AJ.


I don't think it's gmo related but the sub moral of "don't fuck with nature" i could see
much like in the parasprite episode they tried a fast solution rather than a good one
and things went to hell.
0nly this time Fluttershy got caught int he crossfire
but,there may be an even deeper meaning symbolized by that tiny fang at the end.
You can fix what you did wrong but you can't undo it completely.


I want to add that the others were FORCING fluttershy to disobey her cutie mark (which is being kind to animals and being able to comunacate with animals) and make them leave ponyville when they can give bats half the orchard and make a nicer healthier orchard


Heck no! lol it is not right to change the eating habits of the vampire fruit bats, cause what would they eat otherwise if they wont eat apples anymore?!? I have never seen any other fruits besides apples in ponyville XD

I've seen corn but that isn't a fruit XD

Remember the Parasprites episode? Twilight also cast a spell on the Parasprites so they would stop eating all the food; they just resorted to eating houses instead XD. Even animals are genetically modified though, so it's really more of a taboo.


I personally like to think the ponies represent humans, the bats represent nature. Humans see nature as a obstacle in completing something, so they change nature to go there way only ending up with even bigger problems.


I think they should have talked to Granny Smith first. After all, she had seen one before and thus actually knows what's going on... None of them asks her opinion? AJ has had nightmares about bats -- FS just wants to protect them like any other animals... so both are biased. Asking Granny would give a more realistic view...


Hey! Bats is one of my favorite episodes including Its about time , cutie map, and COTLM


WE JUST LEARNED ABOU GMO's IN MY SCHOOL TODAY! also, GMO backwards is OMG.


As a side note, GMOs are ancient history. I mean we've genetically modified dogs, cats, almost all food producing plants, many livestock...

Wait, what do you mean it doesnt count if its not done in a lab, but through selective breeding?!


Hi @The Brony Notion I think you should analyse Suited for Success because the moral can be applied to real life with not putting yourself under too much pressure and letting others boss you about (something I let happen a lot without even realising it XD)


There's a couple I'd like to request that you do next. It's not too many, don't worry. ^^; Anyways, I was wondering if you would maybe do The Best Night Ever, Hurricane Fluttershy, Three's A Crowd, or Inspiration Manifestation? I think it'd be interesting to see your takes on any of those episodes.


At some. Point plz do canterlot wedding and add that if ur going to take someone's place, u should do ur research. 😋<br>


Um, it was mostly Applejack's fault. The second least at fault is Twilight, because she just wanted to be a supportive friend. Applejack was the first to presure her.


Could you consider doing a DPC for "Keep Calm and Flutter On"?


Hey you know...
I guess The GMO of the bat is entered Fluttershy's body by the ultrasonic wave.
But, why can be?


Good morals and Twilight Time because its got alot of morals that we can all learn from


What about Luna eclipse since everypony  in that episode didn't understand how princess Luna feels and would give a second chance in the first place where she arrived. Although the elements of harmony has changed her, the citizens of ponyville are still afraid by looking at Luna by her different appearance since there are similarities between nightmare moon and Luna herself and they shouldn't be afraid by her looks and should forget about the past and not to judge by the looks.


Do the one with Flim and Flam's curative tonic.


The next DPC should be on the episode "Daring Don't"


I think your next episode should be about the origins of the sisters child good or their parents


These vampire bats will give u a fright, eating apples both day and night...

Isn’t that what you do AJ?


Last episode: I think how the original twilight knew was because princess celestia told her long ago and she remembered it during the incident


Is it me or in the song it looks like there r 2 different bats the cute ones and the vampire fruit bats?


Maybe you should do the episode equestrian games,I mean if you ask me that episode had a lot of flaws but that was only because of the way the writer wrote it,if it were someone  else who wrote it,the episode would have most likely made more sense same thing goes with the episode bats


This is my opinion: don't get dirty when you hit round 30


Another Moral: Listen to your friends. Yes the bats were stubborn but Fluttershy knew a lot about bats and all the things she said about the bats, Like the Pollination and the families, were true. Applejack knows that Fluttershy knows a lot about Animals and should've done a better job listening to her friend instead of shoving her aside and saying that what little she knew about the bats was true instead of the stuff Fluttershy was saying.


If anybodys watched the video when they ask if theres elements of unharmony (chaos) then this would link to it because flutterbat is the oppesite of fluttershy so it she would probably represent one of those elements


I would too like to see a dear princess celestia on magical mystery cure.


You should do a DPC on call of the cutie!!!


I think you should do a "what if pinkie pie didn't have friends? " what does she end up like her sister Maud? It has shown in other episodes such as when it was her birthday she thought her friends didn't like her anymore. And then she went more crazy than normal.


U know when fluttershy try to talk with the bats,What if the bats said yes to leave the apples alone.But then turned fluttershy into a bat because she gave in to turn them into something else.Because vampires are supposed to turn other creatures into bats.


i would say the moral is that you care about how your friend feels and not about what you think +cough+ applejack


Could you make DPC on the first two parter


Sounds like dpc 5 ticket master where main 5 put pressure onto twilight


I have a fabulous thing to talk about. Why is Rarity's so called destiny nothing to do with fashion?


Please do DPC for Stare Master or Castle Mane-ia


1:01
Other 5?

Spike: IM RIGHT HERE YOU KNOW!!
Me: Poor thing getting left out probably because he’s not really part of the main Six.


DPC on 'A Canterlot Wedding'  ! It approaches so many current problems, it is a must!


Do more stuff about the ponies maybe like who there parents are.......or explain there element like how pinkies looks nothing like her cutie mark but than she has one that is just like her while all the other ponies have one looking like their cutie mark


you forgot main moral in every episode friendship is magic


You might be biased since Fluttershy is your best pony/mane 6...


You should anylize A Royal Canterlot Wedding. ( I think that's what it's called.) So it's a bigger episode(s). Why not do it.


No it will made the bats worst by transforming them into demons with the tase of pony Magic


you forgot to put the theme of every episode - FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC


I have a conspericy theory. I Think Bats! Was a 22 minute Propaganda Episode made by organic produce companies To Not Buy GMOs.


Do one about Lyra heartstrings or about is nightmare moon lunas real sister? Is Luna hiding a secret? Is discord good forever? Something like that you pick


That face in the end is involve with your future project isn't it?

I suggest keep calm and flutter on and flight to the finish.


JUST PLEASE TALK ABOUT MANE 6's BRONY
SELVES!!!!!!!!!


Can you do a poll for favorite siren from Rainbow Rocks?

.....Even though I know most people are going to choose Sonata.....But, I DO want to know which would come in second: Aria or Adagio? Hmm........


DO A MORAL FOR A CANTERLOT WEDDING!!!!!!!<br>also,are u American or Canadian?

DO A MORAL FOR A CANTERLOT WEDDING!!!!!!!
also,are u American or Canadian?


Ok. Let's Look at this problem for another point of View... first the problem: the bat's are eating all the apple's in applejack's farm. So they should have Focus on geting rid of the bat's... they was not going to kill the bat's! But they chose another way, and fluttershy just bad to use the stare. Applejack's farm and business depended on it! And she didn't want to for some  reason! Like it's just like if some animal started to eat HER crop's She had planted on her own, what would she do then asked them politely to please stop!?

Considering the fact that Fluttershy can talk to animals and represents the element of kindness, yes she would kindly ask if they could go somewhere else.
And she would organize an alternative food source for them.
And the vampire fruit bats need the apples for food, just like the ponies and for that they take what they can get.
It may be that the ponies have claimed these trees for themselves but the bats don't understand that and their stomachs and survival instincts don't care.
Applejack is not evil because she wants the apples to be on the plate of those she intended them for, but neither are the vampire fruit bats, just because they follow their instincts.


Brony Notion I am not just talking about me but I think you should comment more on what we think of the insures (that are really good)


YOU FORGOT ONE MORAL FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC!


How about doin the Canterlot wedding episodes


Don't be to hard on the other 5 of the main six....they each were effected in different ways....Applejack's is obvious she'd loose everything...her farm....what would happen to her family? She panicked.....and when she panicked she caused the others to panic since they probably need her farm for food...plus in previous episodes they also are a big export of Ponyville. Howmuch money would the town loose then as well? You have to think....the Apple Family might be rich...most likely are. But all their money goes back to their farm. Any farmer or shop keeper would know it takes money to make money. I bet after taking care of all the stuff they need to on the farm I bet they only have enough left for food... If their farm is the biggest export then the town would loose money....what would help fund the school or the Dr. Offices? So on...people do crazy things when they panicked or get scared.


This is why I think fluttershy is a little better at friendship then twilight


Or how blue blood is related to the sisters without a connection of anysort


wait vampire bats dont eat apples its fruit bats that dose


May you do a dear Celestia video for the episode  part 1 & 2 discord is back


Magical mystery cure, Twilight time, and Equestria games?


These vampire. Bats will. Give. You a fright


Plz can you do imagination manifestation?


So what's with the picture at the end is that ghost rider's face?


What is the tickets were some form of friendship test from Celestia


think you should review rainbow falls (aka soarin and rainbow dash shipping)


Can you do party of one pleeeeeeeeese!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


I think u should make one about "rarity takes Manhattan" or something like that


This also goes with your aj flaws video.


Are you a changeling?  Cuz i can defeat you


can you analyze what my cutie mark is telling me???


My fav episode is: .................………………….......... Feeling pinkie kean!!!!


now I look at your OC I see that

your OC is a mare


Why are all your question marks backwards?


why did I just see a picture of (who was it again???) at the end


Can you do super speedy cider squeezy 6000?

I already have! It was the first DPC, so it was before I upgraded my OC :3
Here's a link! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UU2xZYVc4FA&index=1&list=PLMSxvcxNbNGATv-h64XTRrKPPTmxEhwsq


Can you did you do equestria girls rainbow rocks please?


Try worlwind fluttershy plus in the apple family reunion the make a bat rainbow did what I'm saying is did the paint the bats  if they did what would get them to say and fly like they(maybe twilights spell)


Is apple jack using GMOs on her prized apple

That's also why the bats haven't eaten the big apple cause it had gmos


where is the moral frend ship is magic did you forget it or...


what? what about the friendship is magic moral?


Plz plz plz do Return of Harmony at least before Christmas plz?!?!?!?!?!


Cutie mark chronicles or just for sidekicks


Next episode : "sezonul 5" . Your ideeas , like , new evil come ...Like Princes Celestia is transformate in PRINCES OF BLAK SUN (!!!!!!) , becose somthing evil make the transformation , or a monster how kill or do somthing horrible to Luna and Celestia parents ..WERE ARE THEI??? Wath you think?????? Pleeeas make a episod!!! I LOVE YOUR EPISODES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (sory I don't write very good , pffff, I am romanian , not english end that is all I  know )


Saying GMOs cause cancer is like thinking Vaccines cause Autism.


Inter view the first part of eqestria girls🐱🙏


Please can I have a shout out you vids are so cool!


can you do a vidio of talking about season and equestria girls 3


What twilight said wasint true here is the real story of how fluttershy was flutterbat. Fluttershy was the dauter of some bat ponies so shes a hybird of a pony and a bat pony but she wasint a bat pony yet after she fell out of the sky and got her cutie mark she was invited to a party by pinkie pie and she might all the mane six ecpet twlight and rainbow dash and she told them that she was half bat pony and well it was night she coudint sleep and then in the episode bats (where she was a teen ) that was the first sign of her bat pony thing and after the thing when they where writting in the jornal she just got her fangs

And also I think that shes the daughter of gueen amber the queen of light that is traped in a stone preson


What's with the face at the end?❔❓🇶🇺🇪🇸🇹🇮🇴🇳...🇲🇦🇷🇰...


Can you do an episode about rainbow roocks since they showed twilights true human self at the end is sunset shimmers true self going to come.in to play?

He also mentioned her in the video he did if there was 2 sunsetshimers in the human world and 2 twilights in equstia

I talked about human Twilight at the end of DPC #4:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWIlclQDPc8&list=PLMSxvcxNbNGATv-h64XTRrKPPTmxEhwsq&index=4

DPC #6 is all about Rainbow Rocks :D


Technically i was first i was just writing a big message lol


Yeah :] let's all say first even if you wern't first of comment or view